Wednesday 24 February 2010

An Average Dismissal? rant about education and bad statistics

It was on my I google news, I had to read it...
"(CNN) -- A school board in Rhode Island has voted to fire all teachers at a struggling high school, a dramatic and controversial plan aimed at shoring up education in a poverty-ridden school district.
On Tuesday night, the board approved the plan by Frances Gallo, superintendent at Central Falls School District, to discharge 88 teachers at Central Falls High School."

ALL the teachers, NOT A SINGLE ONE that was capable...Did they fire the principal that hired and managed 88 incompetent teachers? (bet they didn't)...

SO HOW BAD WERE THEY? you ask.

"The firings come over the district's concern that teachers refused to spend more time with students to improve test scores." AHA, Was the superintendent ready to PAY them to spend additional time... time outside their contracted 5, 6 or 7 hours a day of classroom instruction??? (oh, they didn't say anything about that.)... Try to imagine another profession where that kind of demand would even be suggested... Hmm, are all the bankers who got us into this economic mess actually putting in extra hours at lower pay to help us get out...(pssst.. the correct answer is No.)..

But a teachers' union spokesman called the firings "drastic."

As my students would say....DUH!!!

And now the part I love, they use statistics.... (ummm poorly)...
"The spokesman also cited a 21 percent rise in reading scores and a 3 percent hike in math scores in two years."
Ok, What does that mean? What scores went up 21%.. Try to guess. Does that mean the median national percentile for the school went up by 21 percentile points ? Were they at the 20th percentile and now they are at the 24th (a 21% increase) or did they perhaps go from the 20th percentile to the 41st percentile (an increase of 21 percentile points).. Does it mean that EVERY kid in the school improved 21% over his previous (raw score? natl percentile score ?) WHAT DID THAT MEAN???

And of course, the article concludes with a stunning judgment of the school and the community...."Central Falls is one of the lowest-performing schools in Rhode Island." (Wow, at some schools they probably just took the teachers out and shot them...)

The statistics students in my class have already learned to ask..."Measured HOW?" Do they have the smallest number of people in the theater program? (see, that is a pun on "lowest performing"... rim shot please.... and it might be the truth.. we really don't know)

I have no idea how good, or bad the teachers in Central Falls are, but I am willing to wage heavy odds that they almost certainly are not the 88 worst teachers in Rhode Island. In fact (no elementary or middle school teachers were dismissed???) they may not be the 88 worst teachers in Central Falls... Wait one more wager... I be the superintendent is about to become much more familiar with the ins and outs of class action law suits...
and amazingly, there will be lots of people lined up to interview to work there next year... Eddie Izzard does a nice routine on the Anglican church in which the punch line is "Death or cake?" and in this economy, there will be people lined up to say.. "Death, please."...And now Mr. Ballew has left the soap box...next speaker...

10 comments:

dan.mackinnon said...

Pat - I appreciate your rant. Rants that expose school board foolishness, shameless statistics abuse, or just general stupidity are particularly welcome :) Please, feel free to step up on the soap box anytime!

Anonymous said...

Thank you for taking the time out from your (wonderful) math to speak out. I appreciate and applaud your voice.

Jonathan

Dave L. Renfro said...

Regarding Dan M.'s comment about "Rants that expose school board foolishness", there's probably quite a bit of blog-rant material (for whoever wants to step up to the plate) to be found in the Clayton County (Georgia) School Board's failings.

The details are easy to find on the internet, but here are a couple places to begin:

http://alt.coxnewsweb.com/ajc/pdf/sacsreport.pdf

http://www.wsbtv.com/news/17323636/detail.html

What follows is from the bottom of

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clayton_County,_Georgia

The 50,000-student school system was the first in the nation to lose accreditation since 1969. The Southern Association of Colleges and Schools (SACS) revoked the school district's accreditation on August 28, 2008[9]. This makes only the second system in the nation to do so since 1960. A grand jury investigated and considered possible criminal indictments against the Clayton County School Board. At issue was whether the school board committed malfeasance in ignoring the shortcomings of the school system and violating its own rules concerning the awarding of bids of contracts.

DM Somnath said...

There are several benefits to residing in UAE. One of them is the chance to get a Filipino maid job in Kuwait and other gulf countries with the best Filipino maid salary in Kuwait and other gulf countries to assist people in everyday chores. There is so much to do in gulf countries that you don’t want anything to get in the way.

DM Somnath said...

Nepali Housemaid jobs: When you are on holiday, Nepali House Maid in Kuwait and other gulf countries do important tasks such as removing our trash cans at night, as well as cleaning floors, making beds, and cleaning furniture in our rooms.

DM Somnath said...

The majority of UAE residents have a hectic schedule between work and home and need Sri Lankan House Maid in Kuwait and other gulf countries. They don’t have enough time to vacuum and take care of other household chores. So, they search for help with house cleaning, ironing, washing, and other chores. In the UAE, 360degreejobs

ARUN KUMAR said...

360degreejobs.com is a Leading Online Job and Recruitment Portal which provides ac technician, air conditioner repairman, home cleaning professionals, house cleaning, housemaid services, maintenance services, plumbing services, security guard services.

Call Us :- +91-9654271931

ARUN KUMAR said...

Learn Sanskrit Online with Ziyyara's One-on-One learn sanskrit online Platform. Ziyyara makes Sanskrit learning easy with simple steps from experienced online tutors.

ARUN KUMAR said...

In the era of 21st century Online Tuition is becoming a very common word, every second person knows what online tuition is. If you are not aware of the difference between online tuition and old-way tuition or just tuition.

ARUN KUMAR said...

Best Online Tuition website, Online coaching classes for 1st to 12th grade CBSE IGCSE ICSE, Ziyyara is an online tuition website teaching students online.